I read about it in “Enchanted Island,” by Walter Lowrie, an American academic/cleric who lived for a short time in the late 40s in a villa near the top of Punta Caruso. He writes that he got possession of the painting, and arranged for it to be presented as a gift to one “Sacerdote Onofrio Buonocore.” The picture above by Lefebvre of Colonna is the only one I could find on Google. If it’s here on the island, I’d love to go see and photograph it.
Below is a letter to Lowrie that he put in his book. It confirmed that the painting had arrived on Ischia:
Ischia, June 24, 1948.
Distintissimo Signore e Squistissima Signora,
So yesterday, as we had planned, a solemn session in honor of the Lowries was held in the aula Magna of the Antoniana….Monsignore the Bishop could not himself be there….However, he had come to the Antoniana a few days earlier to admire the picture which has filled the island with wonder. Everybody who has come here after that miracle of art was placed in its permanent position has been overwhelmed with admiration—all of them. I believe that as the news of this masterpiece is gradually spread throughout Italy it will not attract the islanders only….
The picture has been hung in the great hall, above the bookcase at the further end, facing every one who enters the roo. It shines there as a solemn monument. It fills all the hall. On the frame of the bookcase which supports the picture is the inscription: THE SPOUSES WALTER AND BARBARA LOWRIE…
My dearest greeting and many of them. I pray the Lord to bestow upon you every good thing and to deliver you from all evil.
Sacerdote Onofrio Buonocore